Building Trust Through Words: The Power of Consistency and Credibility

As we near the end of our week-long journey through Frank Luntz’s “Words That Work,” we turn our attention to two critical elements of effective communication: consistency and credibility. For City Managers, these principles are not just communication strategies—they’re the bedrock of public trust and effective governance.

The Trust Equation

In the complex world of municipal leadership, trust is your most valuable currency. Luntz emphasizes that consistency in messaging and credibility in delivery are key to building and maintaining this trust. As a City Manager, your words don’t just convey information—they shape perceptions, influence decisions, and ultimately, define your leadership.

Consistency, Credibility, and the ABCs of Impactful Leadership

These principles align perfectly with all three elements of our ABC framework:

1. Awareness: Being mindful of how your words and actions are perceived over time. It’s about recognizing the ripple effects of your words and adjusting your approach to ensure your message is received as intended across all contexts.
2. Balance: Maintaining consistency in your communication across both professional and personal spheres. This means being equally trustworthy and credible whether you’re addressing the city council or having a heart-to-heart with your spouse or friends. It’s about integrating your authentic self across all areas of your life.
3. Cultivation: Fostering a culture of transparency and reliability within your organization and community. This involves nurturing open and honest communication throughout your organization. By consistently demonstrating credibility and follow-through, you cultivate an environment of trust that permeates your municipality, leading to stronger, more authentic connections across the board.

Strategies for Enhancing Consistency and Credibility

Let’s explore some practical ways to incorporate these principles into your communication:

1. Develop a Clear Narrative: Create a consistent story about your city’s vision and values. Every communication should reinforce this narrative.
2. Practice Radical Transparency: When challenges arise, address them head-on. Credibility is built not just in times of success, but in how you handle difficulties.
3. Follow Through on Promises: Ensure your words are backed by actions. Consistently delivering on commitments, no matter how small, builds trust over time.
4. Use Data Effectively: Support your messages with reliable data, but present it in a way that’s accessible and meaningful to your audience.
5. Admit Mistakes: When errors occur, acknowledge them promptly and outline your plan to address them. This vulnerability can actually enhance your credibility.
6. Maintain Message Discipline: Ensure that all city communications, across departments, align with your core messages and values.

Real-World Application

Imagine your city is implementing a controversial new waste management program. A consistent and credible communication approach might look like this:

• Before launch: Clearly explain the rationale, backed by data on environmental and economic benefits.
• During implementation: Provide regular updates on progress, acknowledging challenges openly.
• After launch: Share success stories and data on improvements, while also addressing any ongoing issues transparently.

Throughout this process, your core message about the program’s importance and your commitment to community well-being remains consistent, building credibility over time.

The Challenges of Consistency and Credibility

Maintaining consistency and credibility isn’t always easy, especially in the face of changing circumstances or conflicting stakeholder demands. It requires a delicate balance between staying true to your core messages and being flexible enough to adapt when necessary.

NEED HELP PUTTING THESE IDEAS INTO PRACTICE?

Knowing is only half the battle. If you’re ready to turn these insights into real-world results, HaltingWinter is here to help. Our coaching and workshops are designed to bridge the gap between knowledge and action:

1. Mission and Values Workshop: Transform lofty statements into daily practices. We’ll help you create mission and value statements that actually guide decisions and behaviors.
2. Communication Mastery: Practice makes perfect. Hone your communication skills through hands-on exercises tailored to the unique challenges of municipal leadership.
3. Storytelling for Impact: Learn how to turn data into narratives that move people to action. We’ll show you how to use storytelling to inspire your team and engage your community.

Our approach is all about practical application. We don’t just talk about leadership – we help you live it.

Ready to put these ideas to work?
Let’s talk implementation. Schedule a free strategy call HERE.

Your Consistency Challenge

Reflect on a recent city initiative. How consistent was your messaging from conception to implementation? Were there areas where inconsistencies might have eroded trust? How could you improve consistency in future projects?

Share your thoughts or experiences in the comments on my LinkedIn page. Your insights could provide valuable lessons for other City Managers facing similar challenges.

Remember, building trust through consistent and credible communication is an ongoing process. To continue refining your leadership and communication skills, don’t forget to subscribe to our weekly newsletter, The Leader’s Lens, and tune in to our podcast for more practical insights.

Tomorrow, we’ll wrap up our series with a deep dive into implementing all we’ve learned this week. Until then, keep building trust through your words and actions!

---

Seth Winterhalter is President of HaltingWinter Municipal Solutions, dedicated to making stronger cities through stronger leaders. Through executive coaching, consulting, and the Municipal Leadership Development Circle (MLDC), HaltingWinter helps city managers and municipal leaders transform their leadership impact and their organizational culture.